| Year |
Student Athlete |
College/University |
| 2010 |
Ryan Barban |
Misourri Baptist University |
| |
Steve Castillo |
Texas A&M International University |
| |
Ryan Christenson |
Oklahoma State University |
| |
Casey Collins |
New Mexico State University |
| |
Daniel Coulombe |
Texas Tech University |
| |
Landon Joost |
University of New Mexico |
| |
Joseph Lopez |
Arizona State University |
| |
Woody Nisbet |
Coastal Carolina University |
| |
Kyle Ottoson |
Arizona State University |
| 2009 |
Chris Amrhein |
University of Arizona |
| |
Justin Aragon |
University of New Mexico |
| |
Michael Delos |
University of Science and Arts, Oklahoma |
| |
Dean Espy |
UCLA |
| |
Josh Garcia |
University of Arizona |
| |
Mark Guest |
Oral Roberts University |
| |
Brandon Macias |
University of Kansas |
| |
Erik Nordine |
Mesa State University |
| |
Mike Pierce |
University of Texas, San Antonio |
| |
Nico Rosthenhausler |
Oklahoma State |
| |
Austin Wooldridge |
University of Texas, Permian Basin |
| 2008 |
Shane Dyer |
University of Nebraska |
| |
Adam Bailey |
University of Nebraska |
| |
Jordan Whatcott |
University of Utah |
| |
Adam Prange |
Santa Clara University |
| |
Garrett Hanselman |
Charlotte University |
| |
Jason Summers |
University of Northern Iowa |
| |
Jordan Roualdes |
University of Nebraska |
| |
Daniel Romero |
Colorado State University |
| |
Mark Guest |
University of Oklahoma |
| 2007 |
Nathan Arevalo |
Cameron University |
| |
Jayson Brugman |
Central Missouri |
| |
Tom Catomer |
Grand Canyon University |
| |
Jon Flood |
Mesa State University |
| |
Jarett Jackson |
University of Washington |
| |
Jeff Mutchler |
Grand Canyon University |
| |
Colin Oneal |
University of Kansas |
| |
Rashad White |
Prairie View A&M University |
| 2006 |
Phil Anderegg |
Benedictine University |
| |
Brady Arthur |
Oklahoma State University |
| |
Ben Bloom |
Peru State University |
| |
Dustin Brader |
Arizona State University |
| |
Dillon Chaney |
University of Central Oklahoma |
| |
Dan Colella |
Grand Canyon University |
| |
Luke Grow |
Chicago State University |
| |
Joel Johnson |
Univ. of North Carolina-Greensboro |
| |
Tim Martinez |
New Mexico Highlands University |
| |
Bobby Medina |
Benedictine University |
| |
Scott Mueller |
Arizona State University |
| |
Sean Reilly |
Tennessee Tech University |
| |
Trevor Vega |
Grand Canyon University |
| |
Chad Whittle |
Mesa State University |
| 2005 |
CJ Retherford |
Arizona State University |
| |
Josh Tarnow |
University of New Orleans |
| |
Stephen Miller |
Abilene Christian University |
| |
Jesus Luna |
University of Arizona |
| |
Rene Lopez |
Abilene Christian University |
| |
Ernest Moraga |
Wayland Baptist University |
| |
Joe Alvarez |
College of the Southwest |
| 2004 |
Mike Cervantes |
Wayland Baptist University |
| |
Isaac Hess |
Washington State University |
| |
Jacob Palomarez |
Wayland Baptist University |
| |
Chad White |
Grand Canyon University |
| 2003 |
Stephen Acuna |
Mississippi Valley State University |
| |
Geoff Fox |
Mesa State University |
| |
Bryce Gundry |
Trevecca Nazarene University |
| |
Brandon Mahoney |
Nicholls State University |
| |
Eric Pilon |
New Mexico State University |
| |
Ryan Wardein |
Arizona State University |
| 2002 |
Josh Ervin |
Hawaii Pacific University |
| |
Derek Hassler |
Cal Lutheran University |
| |
Joey Newby |
Colorado State University at Pueblo |
| |
Brett Quijada |
Fort Hays State University |
| |
Chad Williams |
Mississippi Valley State University |
| |
Terrence Young |
Wayland Baptist University |
| 2001 |
Carlos Esquer |
Texas A&M-Corpus Christi |
| |
Manuel Gonzalez |
Benedictine College |
| |
Mike Guerrero |
Arizona State University |
| |
Cory Lizaraga |
University of New Mexico |
| |
Kyle Mason |
University of New Mexico |
| |
Joshua Perrault |
Arizona State University |
| |
Joey Reiman |
Grand Canyon University |
| |
Gabe Trevizo |
University of New Orleans |
| 2000 |
Chris Collins |
Trevecca Nazarene University |
| |
Matt Denny |
Grand Canyon University |
| |
Chris Duffy |
Arizona State University |
| |
Donnie Gwinner |
University of Denver |
| |
Jon Shaeffer |
Arizona State University |
| |
Tucker Tomasek |
Eastern Oregon University |
| 1999 |
Tony Barten |
Benedictine College |
| |
Dallas Haught |
University of Arizona |
| |
Bronson Ledbetter |
Benedictine College |
| |
Paul Madrid |
Benedictine College |
| |
Sam Mendoza |
University of Southern Colorado |
| |
Cory Nenabor |
Grand Canyon University |
| |
Jeremy Rankin |
University of Arkansas |
| |
Paul Rottman |
Cumberland University |
| |
Brett Stehle |
Point Loma University |
| |
Kevin Uhles |
University of New Orleans |
| |
Brandon Wells |
University of New Mexico |
| 1998 |
Sammy Cooper |
University of New Orleans |
| |
Justin Cowan |
University of Nebraska |
| |
Shaylar Hatch |
Arizona State University |
| |
Todd Interdonado |
University of North Carolina-Wilmington |
| |
EJ Martinez |
University of Utah |
| 1997 |
John Watson |
University of New Orleans |
| |
Steve Quezada |
Wayland Baptist University |
| 1996 |
Tony Adkins |
Mesa State University |
| |
Jeremy Aikens |
Grand Canyon University |
| |
Jim Blancarte |
University of New Mexico |
| |
Cody Ransom |
Grand Canyon University |
| |
Kenny Vawter |
University of North Carolina-Asheville |
| 1995 |
Todd Eastin |
McNeese State University |
| |
Robert Hewes |
Northwest Louisiana State University |
| |
Greg Smith |
Upper Iowa University |